Skip to main content

Marriages and democracy : At the heart of the idea of democracy is the freedom to make choices

Interesting article on Arrange Marriages Hope you like it.

(This is the article by Mobius Strip Ramesh Ramanathan. You can visit the this at livemint.com also.)


My parents celebrated their 50th wedding anniversary a few months ago.

They have a good marriage in many ways, but importantly, a balanced one. Balanced in the sense that my mother gets her way on many family issues. But it wasn’t like this when she got married. Theirs was an arranged marriage, in the classic Indian tradition, where the elders (read fathers) decide on one’s choice of life partner. When the news of the arrangement reached her, she had only two requests — not demands — of her father.











We Indians hold different views on public versus personal
choices: political
rights versus choice of a life
partner







“The first”, she told me, with her usual smiling eyes, “was that I could finish my studies in music.” She was in her final year degree at Stella Maris in Madras, and was passionate about the subject.


“The second was that I didn’t want to pierce my nose!” she laughed at the seeming silliness of the request. But she was only 18 at the time.


She didn’t get either of her requests, unfortunately.


The practice of arranged marriages is common even today in India, where parents and elders decide the life partners for their children. Of course, many Indian families have moved to a form of “facilitated arranged marriage”, where the elders initiate the meetings, and then leave the actual decision to the potential partners. However, there still are hundreds of thousands of extreme arranged marriages, or “forced arranged marriages” in India, in which there is no choice available to the individuals concerned, often the woman.


I’m not going to dwell on the relative merits of these different forms of marriage. I want to focus instead on the extreme arranged marriage form where there is little or no choice, and look at it in a different context. What does this practice say about us as a democracy?


Given the nature of the term, there is no single definition for democracy. But the oracle of collective wisdom — Wikipedia — says, “‘Democracy’ is a form of government in which the supreme power is held completely by the people under a free electoral system.”


The stuff we learn in our civics books. But importantly, it goes on to state that there are “two principles that any definition of democracy include. The first principle is that all members of the society have equal access to power and the second that all members enjoy universally recognized freedoms and liberties.” Essentially, that each individual has the right to voice their minds on issues.


So, at the heart of the idea of democracy is the freedom to make choices. But when we talk of democracy and choices, we tend to confine these to “public” issues: should India sign the nuclear treaty, what should be the resolution in Singur, should we have reservations in our IITs? We hold different views on these issues. But we all agree that we have the right to express our view, and engage in constructive debate.

This is at the heart of democracy.


Over the past 60 years, Indians have shown that we are passionate about protecting these rights. Time and again we have shown that we cherish this concept called democracy and that we wouldn’t have it any other way, even if it means slowing our progress as a nation in material or economic terms.


So, how come we are so passionate about protecting our political rights — wanting to have a choice to make decisions about our roads and schools and hospitals — but so completely comfortable with giving up choice in the single biggest decision that impacts our lives — that of a life partner?


How come we hold different views on public versus personal choices?

Among the hundreds of blogs on arranged marriages, I found this interesting point made by a blogger called Shef:


“Arranged marriages can work and they can also fail. Love marriages can work and they can also fail. The point (is) the higher principle: Should people have a choice about who they marry? It’s a bit like democracy vs dictatorship — arranged marriages smack of ‘We know what’s best for you’. Sure, the results can be OK sometimes. But do those good days justify the system?” (To see the full thread, go to www.zackvision.com/weblog/2003/06/arranged-marriage.html)

There are clearly conflicts in the positions between arranged marriages and democratic choice. So, are we a schizophrenic society, in the sense that we live in compartmentalized worlds, comfortable with the contradictions in these positions?


Or, alternatively, should we see our grand adventure with democracy in a completely different light?

As a kind of escapist therapy to relieve the oppression that so many of us face in our daily lives. Maybe we see elections not as an expression of choice, but as periodic national healing sessions — the polling booth as counselling centre.


Ramesh Ramanathan is co-founder, Janaagraha. Möbius Strip, much like its mathematical origins, blurs boundaries. It is about the continuum between the state, market and our society. We welcome your comments at mobiusstrip@livemint.com



StumbleUpon ToolbarAdd to Technorati Favorites






Comments

Popular posts from this blog

वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे (Vaishnav Jan to tene kahiye)

वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे
पीड़ परायी जाणे रे

पर दुख्खे उपकार करे तोये
मन अभिमान ना आणे रे
वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे ...

सकळ लोक मान सहुने वंदे
नींदा न करे केनी रे
वाच काछ मन निश्चळ राखे
धन धन जननी तेनी रे
वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे ...

सम दृष्टी ने तृष्णा त्यागी
पर स्त्री जेने मात रे
जिह्वा थकी असत्य ना बोले
पर धन नव झाली हाथ रे
वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे ...

मोह माया व्यापे नही जेने
द्रिढ़ वैराग्य जेना मन मान रे
राम नाम सुन ताळी लागी
सकळ तिरथ तेना तन मान रे
वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे ...

वण लोभी ने कपट- रहित छे
काम क्रोध निवार्या रे
भणे नरसैय्यो तेनुन दर्शन कर्ता
कुळ एकोतेर तारया रे
वैष्णव जन तो तेने कहिये जे ...

Vaishnav Jan to tene kahiye
Jay peerh paraaye janneyray
Par dukkhey upkar karey teeyey, man abhiman na anney ray
Sakal lokma Sahuney bandhey,
Ninda Na karye kainee ray
Baach kaachh, Man nischal Raakhey, dhan-dhan jananee tainee ray
Samdrishi nay trishna tyagee, par-stree jaynay mat ray
Vivihva thaki asatya na bolay, par-dhan nav jhaley haath ray
Moh maaya vyaayey nahin Jeynay, dridth vairagya jana manma ray

Soil Vs Water

He Raje...Mi shivaji raje Bhosale Boltoy Song Lyrics - Singer Sukhwinder

I have searched on the net but I did not find the lyrics for this song so I am putting it here. Hope you will like it.

he raje ji r ji r ji ji ji har mahadev har mahadev har mahadev har mahadev
har mahadev he raje ji r ji r ji ji ji raje he ji ji ji
zatakun tak ti rakh navyane jaag petu de aag marathi aata dolyane fute angaar bhadak raktaat jagude bhavani maata
he raje ji r ji r ji ji ji raje he ji ji ji har mahadev har mahadev har mahadev har mahadev
(mantra...)
hrydayat jagude punha ata rangada josh dahi dishi ghumude shiv chatrapaticha gosh
jay bhavani jay shivaji
ladhnya sangram aaj ha bal de ya mangati amha karnya sanhar shtruchya janma ghe punha ata
he raje ji r ji r ji ji ji raje he ji ji ji
(mantra...)
talvaar nachate rani aisa petato raag jaga mara jiv ha fule maharashtrachi baag
jaganya sidhant aaj ha shakti de shat pati amha salsalte oth ghalate saad marathi aata
he raje ji r ji r ji ji ji raje he ji ji ji
zatakun tak ti rakh navyane jaag petu de aag marathi aata dolyane fute angaar bhadak rakta…